Very similar to the “retro meatballs” of yore, this sauce goes beyond just grape jelly and chili sauce. With the additional ingredients, the depth of flavor is slightly more pronounced.

If you grew up with go-go boots, hot pants, princess phones, and avocado green kitchens, you probably remember when saucy meatballs first became the rage at neighborhood parties in the ‘burbs. The secret ingredient was (drumroll, please)… grape jelly!

According to Southern Living, it’s still the secret ingredient, bringing a sweetness to the heat and spice of companion ingredients like chili sauce and barbecue sauce. And we still love those sweet-tangy-saucy little bites. They’re always crowd pleasers in the South (hey, in the North too), and they’re strictly a dump-and-stir proposition, leaving plenty of time to attend to other party chores.

Our preferences lean toward savory as opposed to sweet, so we upped the chili sauce by 25%. The recipe is easily finessed to appeal to your personal preferences. For instance, you could reduce the amount of grape jelly to lower the sweetness factor even more; double the mustard to 2 teaspoons; and/or use a tangier BBQ sauce. Another change we made was to the quantity of meatballs. The original recipe called for two pounds and we used three-and-a-quarter pounds, but did not increase the other ingredients.

Easy-Peasy, just whisk together the sauce and give your slow cooker a spritz of cooking spray. In go the meatballs, in goes the sauce. Toss. Cook. Done.

Sprinkle chives on top before serving. Actually, you don’t even have to serve them. Just place a container of toothpicks next to your slow cooker, and guests can serve themselves. Try them and find out why this groovy appetizer from back in the day is once again a hit.

Adapted from a recipe for Southern Living